Toilet keeps running

A toilet that keeps running is leaking water somewhere inside the tank — either down through the flapper into the bowl, or over the top of the overflow tube. The two leaks have different fixes, so the first check works out which one you have.

First checks — these apply to every brand

  1. Find out where the water is going — Watch the tank finish a refill. If water is spilling over the top of the overflow tube, the problem is the fill valve or the water level — go to those checks. If it is not, mark the water level on the inside of the tank with a pencil, turn the supply valve off, and wait at least 25 minutes: if the level has dropped below your mark, water is leaking down through the flapper or flush valve.
  2. Check the flapper seal — This is the most common cause: a worn, warped or gritty flapper lets tank water seep into the bowl, the level drops, and the fill valve tops it up again — the cycle that makes a toilet refill by itself every so often. Wipe the flapper edge and the seat it lands on clean, and replace the flapper if it feels stiff or looks warped, matching the 2-inch or 3-inch size. On tower-style canister flush valves there is no flapper; the replaceable seal at the base of the canister is the equivalent part.
  3. Check the chain length — A chain that is too tight holds the flapper slightly off its seat so it can never seal, and one with too much slack can slip under the flapper and hold it open that way. Set the chain so it hangs with just a little slack when the flapper is closed — about 1/2 inch by Fluidmaster's measure, or 1 to 2 links by Korky's — and re-hook any excess so it cannot wander under the flapper.
  4. Check the fill valve shuts off — If water keeps flowing after the tank is full, dirt and debris lodged inside the fill valve can stop it sealing. Fluidmaster's fix is to flush the valve out: water off, twist the cap an eighth of a turn to remove it, hold a cup upside down over the open valve, turn the supply on full for 10 to 15 seconds to blast the debris out, then refit the cap. If the valve still will not shut off after cleaning, replace it.
  5. Check the overflow tube and the water level — The water should stop roughly 1/2 inch below the top of the overflow tube; if the float is set higher, the tank overfills forever. Lower the float with the valve's adjustment screw and flush to reset the level. If the pencil-mark test showed the level dropping to a point partway down the overflow tube itself, the tube or flush valve is cracked and leaking, and the flush valve needs replacing.

Which is yours?

It runs constantly and never really stops - Water is probably spilling into the overflow tube because the fill valve is set too high, clogged with debris, or failing to shut off. Start with the fill valve and water level checks.

It refills by itself every so often, then goes quiet - That on-off cycling — often called ghost flushing — is a slow leak at the flapper: the tank loses water into the bowl until the float drops and the fill valve tops it up. Start with the pencil-mark test and the flapper check.

More plumbing problems: Toilet won't flush · Sink won't drain · Tub or shower drain is slow · Garbage disposal won't run

Parts that commonly fix it

When to call a pro: Call a plumber if a new flapper and a cleaned or new fill valve do not stop it — the flush valve seat is probably damaged — or if you find water on the floor around the toilet, which means a tank, bolt or supply leak rather than a running flush.